Teaching Case - Legislation and Leadership: The Maintenance of Parents Bill Debate

Legislation and Leadership: The Maintenance of Parents Bill Debate


Educator Access
A review copy of this case is available free of charge to educators and trainers. Please create an account or sign in to gain access to this material.

Permission to Reprint
Each purchase of this product entitles the buyer to one digital file and use. If you intend to distribute, teach, or share this item, you must purchase permission for each individual who will be given access. Learn more about purchasing permission to reprint.

  • Product Description

    To what extent should legislators and legislation be shaped by public opinion? The question lies at the heart of Singapore's 1995 struggle with the issue of whether or not to effectively mandate "filial piety" -- the traditional Asian obligation of children to support their elderly parents. The legislation is proposed by one of Singapore's "nominated" members of Parliament, one who is not elected but, rather, chosen by the Prime Minister in order, it is said, to ensure that a wide range of ideas is placed on the political agenda. But when law professor Walter Woon proposes the "maintenance of parents" bill, an unprecedented level of bitter public opposition surfaces, particularly among the ethnic Chinese who feel that government is overstepping its role and exposing families to potential public humiliation. When the proposal passes more narrowly than is typical in the Singapore Parliament, the Singapore government must decide whether to continue to advance it -- and, if so, what sort of public consultation process might be employed.

    Learning Objective:
    This case raises the question of how the political process accommodates proposals which adherents believe are in the best interest of the majority but which nonetheless face strong opposition.

  • Other Details

    Publication Date: August 01, 1999
    HKS Case Number: 1521.0
    Case Author: Howard Husock
    Faculty Lead: Jose Gomez-Ibanez
    Pages (incl. exhibits): 6
    Setting: Singapore
    Language: English
    Funding Source: The Public Policy Program of the National University of Singapore and the Singapore Civil Service College
    _year: Older than 2000
    _pages: 1-15
    _geography: Asia
  • Warranty Information